Clearly the lucid dream of choice for die-hard Milwaukee Brewers fans has been the pick-up of either Jake Peavy or Erik Bedard to round out the rotation. That has fallen out of favor due to injuries to the two and void left in its wake … I refuse to believe Doug Davis, Jarrod Washburn, or Brad Penny would provide much of a difference. The face they're being mentioned as the next tier of available pitchers means they'll also be too costly.
I haven't noticed anything in Brewersdom about a pitcher hiding in front of our eyes for the past few years … Ian Snell. Thanks to this FanGraphs post, it became clear that Snell has worn out his welcome in Pittsburgh and the feeling is mutual. I don't know the Pirates' inclination to trade within the division (this deal may have soured them forever), but Melvin could make a case for Snell and hope for the best with the "change of scenery" qualifier that works about half the time.
As Dave Cameron at FanGraphs writes, Snell has a FIP of 4.56 … which means he's pitched much better than his ERA indicates. Snell has had his ups and downs in the majors, but sports a decent K rate, doesn't walk a ton, and he isn't injury prone. Not to mention his contract is not cumbersome.
With the current starting rotation woes, I think Snell could plug a hole and pitch six every five games. Pittsburgh appears to be looking for volume players, so perhaps a player stuck at AAA and another from the low minors could do the trick. Of course, many other teams probably have the same idea.
